BDCP Portfolio Debate
Sep 17, 2013
Greg Gartrell —
There are in fact two preposterous arguments being made by the Secretary and Dr. Meral (who has even had the Governor repeat them) on the flooded island scenario. The first is the absurd notion that a megastorm will flood many delta islands filling them with seawater. Dr. Meral should know better; he was around in 1983, the wettest year in the 20th century. The entire San Francisco Bay was full of fresh water. Any island flooding in such circumstances will fill the islands with fresh, not sea, water. The megastorm in the 1860's resulted in a 400 mile freshwater lake in the Central Valley. Sacramento, Ventura and parts of San Diego were abandoned because of flooding ( such storms will hit the entire state). Why anyone would repeat such nonsense that delta island flooding during massive storms would result in the south delta pumps being shut down because of seawater intrusion (that somehow occurs when the flood is putting freshwater out to the Farralons) is baffling.
The second bit of nonsense is that once flooded the south delta will stay salty for up to ten years. Why? Will the earthquake stop the rivers from flowing?
In July 2010 the BDCP presented to the Steering Committee (remember that?) the results of their study on a massive levee failure under an earthquake scenario. They modeled the delta salinity conditions following sudden levee failures on the 15 most vulnerable islands under extreme dry hydrological conditions (October 1990, a critically dry period that extended into 1991 and beyond). One would expect a long period of high salinity in the south delta (the BDCP folks sure did). What they found was that a small storm that occurred in December 1990 was sufficient to freshen the channels: instead of a shutdown lasting 2 years, the south delta channels were fresh again in 4 months. That has never stopped the nonsense unfortunately: never let facts get in the way of a good tall tale.
Numerous studies by DWR, CCWD, and the BDCP have shown that leaving islands flooded in the interior of the delta (i.e. not repairing levees) will reduce salinity intrusion (moving X2 westward), not I crease it. So where exactly does this nonsensical argument that water will be cut off for ten years (or even 2 years) come from? Where are the studies that back up this 10 year claim made by the Secretary and Dr. Meral? If they have them, let's see them. The probability of the earthquake scenario occurring any year is about 2 or 3%. If it occurs in a wet year the delta fills with freshwater or is quickly freshened. To occur under circumstances that result in a year or more outage further reduces the probability. Sunding's analysis shows the cost is overall quite small. Time to end the silly claims and focus on real issues.
Paris, 16 septembre 2013
Nov 30, 2015
Farming In a Desert
But what it really did was expose the lack of knowledge of the "why" we farm a desert as they claim. ... more
Nov 30, 2015
Urban Storm Water
Cities and the suburbs that treat storm(rain) water as a waste product to be disposed of as quickly as possible. ... more
Nov 30, 2015
Is It 80% or 40%?
Using ONLY the 80% number gives the impression that the environment is being stripped of water at an inhuman rate. ... more
Nov 29, 2015
by air, under $100, 3 hours (security check included); by bus, under $75, 6 hours; by car, under $40, 5 hours; ... more
Nov 27, 2015
And I miss all the fresh foods we used to get from California crops. You have to be maybe 45 or older to know what I'm talking about. ... more
Nov 26, 2015
Bullet Train Scrutiny
Let me understand this. The earliest part of the project, the one that can best be understood, engineered, and estimated, is projected to cost 31% more. But... ... more
Nov 26, 2015
Water rates go up, you use less, so welcome to government monopoly ... more
Nov 25, 2015
San Diego Water Surplus
The overlords in Sacramento fear the day that counties like San Diego, and soon Orange County, can tell those politicians to pound sand ... more
Nov 24, 2015
Why Enviros Hate Water
To fix California's water problems we need to create more new fresh water. ... more